Catarina Abril
Badges
No badges yet.
Ratings
4 ratings, newest first
ThrashMovie, 2026
37 out of 100, Insharkurate
Rated 25 October 2026
See Catarina Abril’s ratingHide Catarina Abril’s rating
- Scientific Accuracy
Mixed
What this means for Scientific Accuracy
Accurate and inaccurate elements roughly balance, or the sharks are so stylised (a cartoon or fable whose only impossibility is the fantasy device, such as talking) that the work says little about real sharks either way.
Why this level
Cgi is the best i’ve seen in years species wise. Some good stuff about how bull sharks hunt - murky waters, both saltwater and rivers, opportunistic. Interesting reference to electromagnetic fields. But the human blood in the water as bait is big no. Shaknado-y. “Sharks don’t eat kids” is crazy.
- Motives & Risk
Grossly distorted
What this means for Motives & Risk
Sharks' motives toward people are invented at the core: they hunt people out of human-like malice, revenge or a taste for humans (for example a shark that pursues one family to another ocean).
Why this level
Every bull shark hunts every human that remotely touches the water and not for feed. It bites and lets go and goes onto the next one. Feels personal.
- Ecological Context
Mostly true to nature
What this means for Ecological Context
Right habitat and range; sharks are seen with real prey or other species. At most minor slips, such as a simplified food chain or a species a little out of its range.
Why this level
Quite good and i’ll give a pass to the Great White going up the stream because of the broken levee and saltwater coming into town. Great whites predating on bulls is a bit of a stretch but there is a great shot of Nellie breaching. However Nellie intentionally protecting the pregnant lady is a no.
- Human Impact & Conservation
Distorted
What this means for Human Impact & Conservation
Harm to sharks is shown as normal or without consequence, with no comment. Or the threats are clearly misstated: finning presented as the whole problem, when the main threat is overfishing (sharks caught for meat and fins, and as bycatch); doom claims such as "the oceans will be empty by 2048"; or inflated or outdated figures carrying the argument.
Why this level
Goody two shoes Nellie offsets the view of sharks as killing machines because it feels intentional that she as a pregnant shark protects the pregnant lady. But overall the tone of the movie is degrading and hints that to deal with bull sharks you tase them, spear them, stab them or blow them up.
Hungry Shark EvolutionGame, 2012
19 out of 100, Insharkurate
Rated 24 October 2026
See Catarina Abril’s ratingHide Catarina Abril’s rating
- Scientific Accuracy
Distorted
What this means for Scientific Accuracy
Several clear errors or myths, in either direction, with few accurate elements. Exaggerated: a drop of blood sets off a frenzy, a shark roars. Understated or simply wrong: sharks shown as toothless or harmless by nature, able to live without eating animals, or "sharks don't get cancer".
Why this level
Some species are well portrayed - there is a reef shark, a mako, an hammerhead, a great white. But then there are robot sharks and “godzilla-esque” sharks. Sharks eating bigger sharks then them and frozen food or funny items.
- Motives & Risk
Distorted
What this means for Motives & Risk
Clear distortion of motive or risk dominates. Demonising: encounters framed as attacks, with ominous music, gore, titles or posters, and no sign that bites are rare or have causes. Sanitising: sharks shown as people's devoted friends, guardians or pets, as friends who give up eating, as safe to grab, ride or hug, or the risk to people denied.
Why this level
It has a strong element of the maneater narrative but the purpose being the game is to feed the shark with multiple items among which there are humans, frozen food, bombs.
- Ecological Context
Distorted
What this means for Ecological Context
Habitat, range or prey clearly wrong for the species or place (a great white in a freshwater lake; bull sharks, though, really do enter rivers and lakes), or sharks emptying an area of fish.
Why this level
A lot of innacuracies but some interesting dynamics such as the shark avoiding lionfish because it is venomous, and being stinged by swordfish which does happen in the wild.
- Human Impact & Conservation
Grossly distorted
What this means for Human Impact & Conservation
The picture of human impact is false at its core, either way. Killing or harming sharks is shown as harmless, heroic, fun or the fix for bites (celebrated hunts, culls, trophy kills), or sharks are said to need no protection. Or the reverse: the work's case rests on invented or grossly false figures about the threats.
Why this level
It purely paints sharks as eating machines including human eating machines. No conservation value whatsoever
Into the DeepMovie, 2025
44 out of 100, Partly Sharkurate
Rated 24 October 2026
See Catarina Abril’s ratingHide Catarina Abril’s rating
- Scientific Accuracy
Mixed
What this means for Scientific Accuracy
Accurate and inaccurate elements roughly balance, or the sharks are so stylised (a cartoon or fable whose only impossibility is the fantasy device, such as talking) that the work says little about real sharks either way.
Why this level
There is a mix of not great CGI but not bad that looks like augmented reality with true shark underwater footage of white sharks.
- Motives & Risk
Distorted
What this means for Motives & Risk
Clear distortion of motive or risk dominates. Demonising: encounters framed as attacks, with ominous music, gore, titles or posters, and no sign that bites are rare or have causes. Sanitising: sharks shown as people's devoted friends, guardians or pets, as friends who give up eating, as safe to grab, ride or hug, or the risk to people denied.
Why this level
Motive is unclear, although the movie begins with the father of the main character dying because of a shark during the movie the overall tone is respectfull about us entering “their kingdom” . The shark still goes for the “bad humans” at the end of the day.
- Ecological Context
Mixed
What this means for Ecological Context
True and false elements roughly balance, or the work says too little to judge: a believable setting and nothing more. Also the level for an overstated role in an otherwise true picture ("sharks eat only the sick and weak", "without sharks the ocean dies"). In a factual work, also the level for showing no ecological context at all.
Why this level
White sharks do not naturally occur in Thai waters. There is a whole speech about climate change impacts in their migration patterns so I see what they were trying to achieve. The depiction itself of the shark near a sunken ship and its behavior is decent.
- Human Impact & Conservation
Mixed
What this means for Human Impact & Conservation
True and distorted claims roughly balance, or the work says too little to judge: a generic line ("sharks are in trouble") that names no threat. In a factual work, also the level for saying nothing at all about human impact.
Why this level
During the movie there is an undertone of the main character being affraid of the shark which adds to the human killer narrative but overall I feel that throughout the movie this was debunked. And by the end of the movie you are presented with an incredible call to action from Richard Dreyfuss
The Black DemonMovie, 2023
13 out of 100, Insharkurate
Updated 24 October 2026
See Catarina Abril’s ratingHide Catarina Abril’s rating
- Scientific Accuracy
Grossly distorted
What this means for Scientific Accuracy
The central claims about sharks' bodies or abilities are false: impossible size, senses, powers or behaviour, shown as real or as shark nature in an openly impossible story (sharks that fly through the air to bite, or swim through sand), an extinct species shown alive as a real-world fact, or faked evidence presented as real (a staged special presented as a genuine documentary).
Why this level
Shark changes sizes about 3 times. CGI is foul. At one point the sharks is hunting horizontally and in the next plan it polaris jumps.
- Motives & Risk
Grossly distorted
What this means for Motives & Risk
Sharks' motives toward people are invented at the core: they hunt people out of human-like malice, revenge or a taste for humans (for example a shark that pursues one family to another ocean).
Why this level
The overall tone of “the oil rig has awoken the demon” like oil attracts any wildlife or sharks can get mad at people for building oil rigs is insane.
- Ecological Context
Distorted
What this means for Ecological Context
Habitat, range or prey clearly wrong for the species or place (a great white in a freshwater lake; bull sharks, though, really do enter rivers and lakes), or sharks emptying an area of fish.
Why this level
It does take place in Baja California where Megalodon teeth have been found but I can’t get myself to rate this mixed because it is another “Meg is lurking” movie and that is not accurate.
- Human Impact & Conservation
Distorted
What this means for Human Impact & Conservation
Harm to sharks is shown as normal or without consequence, with no comment. Or the threats are clearly misstated: finning presented as the whole problem, when the main threat is overfishing (sharks caught for meat and fins, and as bycatch); doom claims such as "the oceans will be empty by 2048"; or inflated or outdated figures carrying the argument.
Why this level
Gross depiction of sharks as blood thirsty hounds but the only reason I am not giving it the worst rating of all is that I think the movie director was trying to hint that humans building oil rigs makes sealife upset. A very anthropomorphist way of depicting environmental impacts of oil drilling
Favourites
No favourites yet.
Up next
4 titles
Finished
20 titles
Hungry Shark EvolutionGame, 201219 InsharkurateCommunity1 rating
Into the DeepMovie, 202544 Partly SharkurateCommunity1 rating
Jaws @ 50: The Definitive Inside StoryDocumentary, 202563 SharkurateAI-generated gradeNot rated
The ShallowsMovie, 201631 InsharkurateAI-generated gradeNot rated
Meg 2: The TrenchMovie, 202319 InsharkurateAI-generated gradeNot rated
Posters and cover art from IMDb (via OMDb) (opens in a new tab) and IGDB.com (opens in a new tab).
Catarina Abril is also a verified shark expert.


