Why accurate media portrayal matters
On screen, sharks are almost always a threat, and it matters: what people watch changes how they feel about real sharks, people who fear or dislike an animal are more likely to back killing it, and in New South Wales, shark nets catch mostly animals they are not meant for, threatened ones among them.
In short
- On screen
105 of 109 shark films openly show sharks as a potential threat to people 1.
- In viewers
In one study, about 12 minutes of positively framed shark videos cut viewers' fright by 24 %. Negatively framed videos raised it slightly. 2
The figures are a symbol of less fright; they do not measure it. In one study, the average fright of 172 people went from 5.95 to 4.55 on a scale from 1 (not frightened at all) to 10 (extremely frightened), measured after watching about 12 minutes of positively framed videos.
Two stick figures joined by an arrow labelled 24 % less frightened, a symbol of the result: before, a frightened figure, its head sunk to its shoulders and its arms crossed tight over its chest; after, a calmer figure, standing upright with its arms relaxed at its sides. The figures do not measure the change: the average went from 5.95 to 4.55 on the scale from 1 to 10.
The numbers
| Step | What | Value | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| On screen | Shark films that openly show sharks as a potential threat to people | 105 of 109 (96 %) | 1 |
| On screen | Films that only hint at a threat | 3 | 1 |
| On screen | Films that do not show sharks as a threat | 1 | 1 |
| In viewers | Fright before and after positively framed videos, from 1 (not frightened at all) to 10 (extremely frightened): mean (standard deviation) | 5.95 (2.62) to 4.55 (2.39), down 23.5 % | 2 |
| In viewers | The same, negatively framed videos | 5.53 (2.43) to 5.85 (2.63), up 5.8 % | 2 |
| In viewers | People in each group, the same people before and after | 172 and 168 | 2 |
Chart drawn from the data in 1; the figures are a symbol of the result in 2.
Details and sources: On screen (detailed version), In viewers and the public (detailed version)
From media portrayal to shark conservation
It is extremely challenging to establish the whole pathway from the media portrayal of sharks to effective conservation measures in a single study, but each link along the way has been recorded somewhere.
Portrayal
How films, television, the news, games and books show sharks.
Beliefs and fear
Portraying sharks positively in media can lower fear.
Attitudes
What people believe about sharks goes with what they support.
Behaviour
Concern can turn into action.
Policy and management
Speaking up can help change the rules.
Populations
Protection can bring sharks back.
Diagram: how the steps can link, not measured data.
The evidence for each step (detailed version), and how strong it is, is in the detailed version.
What Sharkuracy does
Sharkuracy.org is a community-driven and expert-backed information library about how accurately movies, TV, documentaries, videogames and books portray sharks.
Why sharks matter sets out what is at stake for real sharks, with sources.
References
Sources for the other claims are in the detailed version.
Reference 2: Casola, W. R., Beall, J. M., Peterson, M. N., Larson, L. R., & Price, C. S. (2022). Influence of social media on fear of sharks, perceptions of intentionality associated with shark bites, and shark management preferences. Frontiers in Communication, 7, 1033347. https://doi.org/10.3389/fcomm.2022.1033347