Beta. The official launch is in early December 2026. Until then, feedback is welcome at hello@sharkuracy.org.

Sharkwater

Documentary, 2006

Sharkuracy index

63out of 100

Sharkurate

Community grade, 1 rating

63out of 100

Sharkurate

Expert grade, 1 ratingSee who rated
Shark role
Central to the work
Audience
General audience

Sign in or create an account to leave your own rating!

Index breakdown

Community grade, 1 rating
  • Scientific Accuracy

    True to nature

    What this means for Scientific Accuracy

    What the work shows or says about sharks' bodies and abilities is true, and its factual claims match current science. Explaining biology or correcting a myth is welcome but not needed.

  • Motives & Risk

    Mostly true to nature

    What this means for Motives & Risk

    Sharks act from natural motives (feeding, curiosity, investigating, defence). Risk to people is real and in proportion, with some dramatic licence (suspense music in one scene, one "attack" headline).

  • Ecological Context

    Mixed

    What this means for Ecological Context

    True and false elements roughly balance, or the work says too little to judge: a believable setting and nothing more. Also the level for an overstated role in an otherwise true picture ("sharks eat only the sick and weak", "without sharks the ocean dies"). In a factual work, also the level for showing no ecological context at all.

  • Human Impact & Conservation

    Distorted

    What this means for Human Impact & Conservation

    Harm to sharks is shown as normal or without consequence, with no comment. Or the threats are clearly misstated: finning presented as the whole problem, when the main threat is overfishing (sharks caught for meat and fins, and as bycatch); doom claims such as "the oceans will be empty by 2048"; or inflated or outdated figures carrying the argument.

Expert grade, 1 rating
  • Scientific Accuracy

    True to nature

    What this means for Scientific Accuracy

    What the work shows or says about sharks' bodies and abilities is true, and its factual claims match current science. Explaining biology or correcting a myth is welcome but not needed.

  • Motives & Risk

    Mostly true to nature

    What this means for Motives & Risk

    Sharks act from natural motives (feeding, curiosity, investigating, defence). Risk to people is real and in proportion, with some dramatic licence (suspense music in one scene, one "attack" headline).

  • Ecological Context

    Mixed

    What this means for Ecological Context

    True and false elements roughly balance, or the work says too little to judge: a believable setting and nothing more. Also the level for an overstated role in an otherwise true picture ("sharks eat only the sick and weak", "without sharks the ocean dies"). In a factual work, also the level for showing no ecological context at all.

  • Human Impact & Conservation

    Distorted

    What this means for Human Impact & Conservation

    Harm to sharks is shown as normal or without consequence, with no comment. Or the threats are clearly misstated: finning presented as the whole problem, when the main threat is overfishing (sharks caught for meat and fins, and as bycatch); doom claims such as "the oceans will be empty by 2048"; or inflated or outdated figures carrying the argument.

How we rate the four criteria

Expert ratings

Verified experts’ ratings of Sharkwater, newest first.

  • Miguel Pessanha Pais

    MARDIVE - Association Science and Education for the Conservation of Marine Biodiversity

    63 out of 100, Sharkurate

    Rated 11 October 2026

    See Miguel Pessanha Pais’s rating
    • Scientific Accuracy

      True to nature

      What this means for Scientific Accuracy

      What the work shows or says about sharks' bodies and abilities is true, and its factual claims match current science. Explaining biology or correcting a myth is welcome but not needed.

      Why this level

      The documentary presents excellent, biologically accurate footage of species like silkies, hammerheads, and Galapagos sharks, correctly highlighting their evolutionary history and sensory abilities.

    • Motives & Risk

      Mostly true to nature

      What this means for Motives & Risk

      Sharks act from natural motives (feeding, curiosity, investigating, defence). Risk to people is real and in proportion, with some dramatic licence (suspense music in one scene, one "attack" headline).

      Why this level

      Stewart swims intimately with sharks to successfully prove they act from natural motives (curiosity and feeding) rather than malice. He occasionally goes a bit overboard with the handling, but avoids treating them like pets you can hug.

    • Ecological Context

      Mixed

      What this means for Ecological Context

      True and false elements roughly balance, or the work says too little to judge: a believable setting and nothing more. Also the level for an overstated role in an otherwise true picture ("sharks eat only the sick and weak", "without sharks the ocean dies"). In a factual work, also the level for showing no ecological context at all.

      Why this level

      Relies on exaggerated catchphrases and doomsday claims that our survival ultimately depends on the survival of sharks. While there are proven cascading effects of removing sharks that can reshape an area, it is not the entire collapse of the ocean.

    • Human Impact & Conservation

      Distorted

      What this means for Human Impact & Conservation

      Harm to sharks is shown as normal or without consequence, with no comment. Or the threats are clearly misstated: finning presented as the whole problem, when the main threat is overfishing (sharks caught for meat and fins, and as bycatch); doom claims such as "the oceans will be empty by 2048"; or inflated or outdated figures carrying the argument.

      Why this level

      The documentary frames shark finning as the main culprit, ignoring the fact that general overfishing and "bycatch" represent the primary threat to populations.

About this documentary

Sharkwater - The Story "An eye-opening film...visually stunning... this movie will change the way you see our oceans." - Bonnie Laufer, Tribute Magazine For filmmaker Rob Stewart, exploring sharks began as an underwater adventure. What it turned into was a beautiful and dangerous life journey into the balance of life on earth. Driven by passion fed from a life-long fascination with sharks, Stewart debunks historical stereotypes and media depictions of sharks as bloodthirsty, man-eating monsters and reveals the reality of sharks as pillars in the evolution of the seas. Filmed in visually stunning, high definition video, Sharkwater takes you into the most shark rich waters of the world, exposing the exploitation and corruption surrounding the world's shark populations in the marine reserves of Cocos Island, Costa Rica and the Galapagos Islands, Ecuador. In an effort to protect sharks, Stewart teams up with renegade conservationist Paul Watson of the Sea Shepherd Conservation Society. Their unbelievable adventure together starts with a battle between the Sea Shepherd and shark poachers in Guatemala, resulting in pirate boat rammings, gunboat chases, mafia espionage, corrupt court systems and attempted murder charges, forcing them to flee for their lives. Through it all, Stewart discovers these magnificent creatures have gone from predator to prey, and how despite surviving the earth's history of mass extinctions, they could easily be wiped out within a few years due to human greed. Stewart's remarkable journey of courage and determination changes from a mission to save the world's sharks, into a fight for his life, and that of humankind.

Language
English
Director
Rob Stewart
Starring
Rob Stewart, Paul Watson, Erich Ritter

IMDb page (opens in a new tab)

Data and poster from IMDb via OMDb (opens in a new tab)

Ratings from other sites

How critics and audiences on other sites rated this documentary. These ratings have no influence on the Sharkuracy index.

IMDb
7.8 out of 10
Average of 5,141 IMDb users’ ratings
Rotten Tomatoes
81%
Critics’ reviews that are positive
Metacritic
59 out of 100
Weighted average of critics’ reviews

From IMDb, Rotten Tomatoes and Metacritic via OMDb (opens in a new tab), as of .