Beta. The official launch is in early December 2026. Until then, feedback is welcome at hello@sharkuracy.org.

Sharkwater Extinction

Documentary, 2018

Sharkuracy index

62out of 100

Partly Sharkurate

Community grade, 1 rating

62out of 100

Partly Sharkurate

Expert grade, 1 ratingSee who rated
Shark role
Central to the work
Audience
General audience

Sign in or create an account to leave your own rating!

Index breakdown

Community grade, 1 rating
  • Scientific Accuracy

    True to nature

    What this means for Scientific Accuracy

    What the work shows or says about sharks' bodies and abilities is true, and its factual claims match current science. Explaining biology or correcting a myth is welcome but not needed.

  • Motives & Risk

    Distorted

    What this means for Motives & Risk

    Clear distortion of motive or risk dominates. Demonising: encounters framed as attacks, with ominous music, gore, titles or posters, and no sign that bites are rare or have causes. Sanitising: sharks shown as people's devoted friends, guardians or pets, as friends who give up eating, as safe to grab, ride or hug, or the risk to people denied.

  • Ecological Context

    Mixed

    What this means for Ecological Context

    True and false elements roughly balance, or the work says too little to judge: a believable setting and nothing more. Also the level for an overstated role in an otherwise true picture ("sharks eat only the sick and weak", "without sharks the ocean dies"). In a factual work, also the level for showing no ecological context at all.

  • Human Impact & Conservation

    Mostly true to nature

    What this means for Human Impact & Conservation

    The main threats and the state of sharks are shown truly. At most minor slips: a dated or rounded figure, one threat given a little too much weight, a solution slightly oversold.

Expert grade, 1 rating
  • Scientific Accuracy

    True to nature

    What this means for Scientific Accuracy

    What the work shows or says about sharks' bodies and abilities is true, and its factual claims match current science. Explaining biology or correcting a myth is welcome but not needed.

  • Motives & Risk

    Distorted

    What this means for Motives & Risk

    Clear distortion of motive or risk dominates. Demonising: encounters framed as attacks, with ominous music, gore, titles or posters, and no sign that bites are rare or have causes. Sanitising: sharks shown as people's devoted friends, guardians or pets, as friends who give up eating, as safe to grab, ride or hug, or the risk to people denied.

  • Ecological Context

    Mixed

    What this means for Ecological Context

    True and false elements roughly balance, or the work says too little to judge: a believable setting and nothing more. Also the level for an overstated role in an otherwise true picture ("sharks eat only the sick and weak", "without sharks the ocean dies"). In a factual work, also the level for showing no ecological context at all.

  • Human Impact & Conservation

    Mostly true to nature

    What this means for Human Impact & Conservation

    The main threats and the state of sharks are shown truly. At most minor slips: a dated or rounded figure, one threat given a little too much weight, a solution slightly oversold.

How we rate the four criteria

Expert ratings

Verified experts’ ratings of Sharkwater Extinction, newest first.

  • Miguel Pessanha Pais

    MARDIVE - Association Science and Education for the Conservation of Marine Biodiversity

    62 out of 100, Partly Sharkurate

    Rated 11 October 2026

    See Miguel Pessanha Pais’s rating
    • Scientific Accuracy

      True to nature

      What this means for Scientific Accuracy

      What the work shows or says about sharks' bodies and abilities is true, and its factual claims match current science. Explaining biology or correcting a myth is welcome but not needed.

      Why this level

      The documentary features biologically accurate footage of species like oceanic whitetips and hammerheads, accurately reflecting their anatomy, vulnerabilities, and real-world behavior.

    • Motives & Risk

      Distorted

      What this means for Motives & Risk

      Clear distortion of motive or risk dominates. Demonising: encounters framed as attacks, with ominous music, gore, titles or posters, and no sign that bites are rare or have causes. Sanitising: sharks shown as people's devoted friends, guardians or pets, as friends who give up eating, as safe to grab, ride or hug, or the risk to people denied.

      Why this level

      Unlike the original Sharkwater, it relies too heavily on Stewart's method of free-diving with and physically hugging sharks to prove they are misunderstood, ending up ignoring the inherent risks of touching, grabbing and harassing wild animals. The boundaries of safe interaction are crossed.

    • Ecological Context

      Mixed

      What this means for Ecological Context

      True and false elements roughly balance, or the work says too little to judge: a believable setting and nothing more. Also the level for an overstated role in an otherwise true picture ("sharks eat only the sick and weak", "without sharks the ocean dies"). In a factual work, also the level for showing no ecological context at all.

      Why this level

      Like with the original documentary, it relies heavily on the claim that sharks hold the stability of the ocean on their backs, and if they die, we can all die.

    • Human Impact & Conservation

      Mostly true to nature

      What this means for Human Impact & Conservation

      The main threats and the state of sharks are shown truly. At most minor slips: a dated or rounded figure, one threat given a little too much weight, a solution slightly oversold.

      Why this level

      This documentary corrects the original's claim that finning is the problem, by providing a much more complete picture of the threats to sharks, and informing about shark-derived products that people unkowingly consume.

About this documentary

Discovering that sharks are being hunted to extinction, and with them the destruction of our life support system - activist and filmmaker Rob Stewart embarks on a dangerous quest to stop the slaughter. Following the sharks - and the money - into the elusive pirate fishing industry, Stewart uncovers a multi-billion dollar scandal that makes us all accomplices in the greatest wildlife massacre ever known.

Language
English
Director
Rob Stewart
Starring
Rob Stewart, Rebecca Aldworth, Will Allen

IMDb page (opens in a new tab)

Data and poster from IMDb via OMDb (opens in a new tab)

Ratings from other sites

How critics and audiences on other sites rated this documentary. These ratings have no influence on the Sharkuracy index.

IMDb
7.5 out of 10
Average of 1,261 IMDb users’ ratings
Rotten Tomatoes
100%
Critics’ reviews that are positive
Metacritic
76 out of 100
Weighted average of critics’ reviews

From IMDb, Rotten Tomatoes and Metacritic via OMDb (opens in a new tab), as of .