Beta. The official launch is in early December 2026. Until then, feedback is welcome at hello@sharkuracy.org.

Playing with Sharks: The Valerie Taylor Story

Documentary, 2021

Sharkuracy index

100out of 100

Highly Sharkurate

Community grade, 1 rating

100out of 100

Highly Sharkurate

Expert grade, 1 ratingSee who rated
Shark role
Central to the work
Audience
General audience

Sign in or create an account to leave your own rating!

Index breakdown

Community grade, 1 rating
  • Scientific Accuracy

    True to nature

    What this means for Scientific Accuracy

    What the work shows or says about sharks' bodies and abilities is true, and its factual claims match current science. Explaining biology or correcting a myth is welcome but not needed.

  • Motives & Risk

    True to nature

    What this means for Motives & Risk

    Natural motives throughout. Where the work deals with risk to people, risk is shown as it is, real but rare, with its circumstances, and with neither sensational framing nor false reassurance; where risk never comes up (a nature documentary), natural motives are enough. Explaining how rare bites are is welcome but not needed.

  • Ecological Context

    True to nature

    What this means for Ecological Context

    Habitat, range, prey and role shown as they are, and any claim about the shark's role is accurate and not overstated (for example grey reef sharks shown hunting groupers at a spawning aggregation). Explaining the ecology is welcome but not needed.

  • Human Impact & Conservation

    True to nature

    What this means for Human Impact & Conservation

    Human impacts, threats and solutions are shown as they are and in proportion. No harm is shown as costless and nothing is exaggerated. Advocacy or a call to action adds nothing; it is judged only on whether its facts are right.

Expert grade, 1 rating
  • Scientific Accuracy

    True to nature

    What this means for Scientific Accuracy

    What the work shows or says about sharks' bodies and abilities is true, and its factual claims match current science. Explaining biology or correcting a myth is welcome but not needed.

  • Motives & Risk

    True to nature

    What this means for Motives & Risk

    Natural motives throughout. Where the work deals with risk to people, risk is shown as it is, real but rare, with its circumstances, and with neither sensational framing nor false reassurance; where risk never comes up (a nature documentary), natural motives are enough. Explaining how rare bites are is welcome but not needed.

  • Ecological Context

    True to nature

    What this means for Ecological Context

    Habitat, range, prey and role shown as they are, and any claim about the shark's role is accurate and not overstated (for example grey reef sharks shown hunting groupers at a spawning aggregation). Explaining the ecology is welcome but not needed.

  • Human Impact & Conservation

    True to nature

    What this means for Human Impact & Conservation

    Human impacts, threats and solutions are shown as they are and in proportion. No harm is shown as costless and nothing is exaggerated. Advocacy or a call to action adds nothing; it is judged only on whether its facts are right.

How we rate the four criteria

Expert ratings

Verified experts’ ratings of Playing with Sharks: The Valerie Taylor Story, newest first.

  • Miguel Pessanha Pais

    MARDIVE - Association Science and Education for the Conservation of Marine Biodiversity

    100 out of 100, Highly Sharkurate

    Rated 11 October 2026

    See Miguel Pessanha Pais’s rating
    • Scientific Accuracy

      True to nature

      What this means for Scientific Accuracy

      What the work shows or says about sharks' bodies and abilities is true, and its factual claims match current science. Explaining biology or correcting a myth is welcome but not needed.

      Why this level

      A true pioneer in underwater cinematography, the documentary perfectly captures the true physical abilities, anatomy, and biology of real-world species.

    • Motives & Risk

      True to nature

      What this means for Motives & Risk

      Natural motives throughout. Where the work deals with risk to people, risk is shown as it is, real but rare, with its circumstances, and with neither sensational framing nor false reassurance; where risk never comes up (a nature documentary), natural motives are enough. Explaining how rare bites are is welcome but not needed.

      Why this level

      The documentary corrects the framing Taylor herself helped create in Jaws, presenting sharks as naturally motivated predators that pose a real but context-dependent risk, while explicitly showing how it is human error (like chaotic hand-feeding) that leads to bites.

    • Ecological Context

      True to nature

      What this means for Ecological Context

      Habitat, range, prey and role shown as they are, and any claim about the shark's role is accurate and not overstated (for example grey reef sharks shown hunting groupers at a spawning aggregation). Explaining the ecology is welcome but not needed.

      Why this level

      The movie accurately captures the ecological context of sharks in vibrant marine ecosystems alongside natural prey and coral reefs,

    • Human Impact & Conservation

      True to nature

      What this means for Human Impact & Conservation

      Human impacts, threats and solutions are shown as they are and in proportion. No harm is shown as costless and nothing is exaggerated. Advocacy or a call to action adds nothing; it is judged only on whether its facts are right.

      Why this level

      Accurately describes the shift toward catastrophic overfishing and shark finning, highlighting Taylor's successful real-world campaigns to protect Grey Nurse sharks, presenting plausible solutions.

About this documentary

Pioneering scuba diver Valerie Taylor, who has dedicated her life to exposing the myth surrounding our fear of sharks.

Genre
Adventure
Language
English
Director
Sally Aitken
Starring
Valerie Taylor, Ron Taylor, Jeremiah S. Sullivan

IMDb page (opens in a new tab)

Data and poster from IMDb via OMDb (opens in a new tab)

Ratings from other sites

How critics and audiences on other sites rated this documentary. These ratings have no influence on the Sharkuracy index.

IMDb
7.5 out of 10
Average of 657 IMDb users’ ratings
Metacritic
78 out of 100
Weighted average of critics’ reviews

From IMDb and Metacritic via OMDb (opens in a new tab), as of .