Beta. The official launch is in early December 2026. Until then, feedback is welcome at hello@sharkuracy.org.

Shark Tale

Movie, 2004

Sharkuracy index

7out of 100

Critically Insharkurate

Community grade, 2 ratings

7out of 100

Critically Insharkurate

Expert grade, 2 ratingsSee who rated
Shark role
Central to the work
Audience
Children

Sign in or create an account to leave your own rating!

Index breakdown

Community grade, 2 ratings
  • Scientific Accuracy

    Distorted

    What this means for Scientific Accuracy

    Several clear errors or myths, in either direction, with few accurate elements. Exaggerated: a drop of blood sets off a frenzy, a shark roars. Understated or simply wrong: sharks shown as toothless or harmless by nature, able to live without eating animals, or "sharks don't get cancer".

  • Motives & Risk

    Grossly distorted

    What this means for Motives & Risk

    Sharks' motives toward people are invented at the core: they hunt people out of human-like malice, revenge or a taste for humans (for example a shark that pursues one family to another ocean).

  • Ecological Context

    Grossly distorted

    What this means for Ecological Context

    The picture of sharks in nature is false at its core: an impossible habitat or range shown as real (a prehistoric species alive in the deep sea), sharks as a plague the ocean would be better without, or people as their usual prey.

  • Human Impact & Conservation

    Distorted

    What this means for Human Impact & Conservation

    Harm to sharks is shown as normal or without consequence, with no comment. Or the threats are clearly misstated: finning presented as the whole problem, when the main threat is overfishing (sharks caught for meat and fins, and as bycatch); doom claims such as "the oceans will be empty by 2048"; or inflated or outdated figures carrying the argument.

Expert grade, 2 ratings
  • Scientific Accuracy

    Distorted

    What this means for Scientific Accuracy

    Several clear errors or myths, in either direction, with few accurate elements. Exaggerated: a drop of blood sets off a frenzy, a shark roars. Understated or simply wrong: sharks shown as toothless or harmless by nature, able to live without eating animals, or "sharks don't get cancer".

  • Motives & Risk

    Grossly distorted

    What this means for Motives & Risk

    Sharks' motives toward people are invented at the core: they hunt people out of human-like malice, revenge or a taste for humans (for example a shark that pursues one family to another ocean).

  • Ecological Context

    Grossly distorted

    What this means for Ecological Context

    The picture of sharks in nature is false at its core: an impossible habitat or range shown as real (a prehistoric species alive in the deep sea), sharks as a plague the ocean would be better without, or people as their usual prey.

  • Human Impact & Conservation

    Distorted

    What this means for Human Impact & Conservation

    Harm to sharks is shown as normal or without consequence, with no comment. Or the threats are clearly misstated: finning presented as the whole problem, when the main threat is overfishing (sharks caught for meat and fins, and as bycatch); doom claims such as "the oceans will be empty by 2048"; or inflated or outdated figures carrying the argument.

How we rate the four criteria

Expert ratings

Verified experts’ ratings of Shark Tale, newest first.

  • Miguel Pessanha Pais

    MARDIVE - Association Science and Education for the Conservation of Marine Biodiversity

    8 out of 100, Critically Insharkurate

    Rated 11 October 2026

    See Miguel Pessanha Pais’s rating
    • Scientific Accuracy

      Distorted

      What this means for Scientific Accuracy

      Several clear errors or myths, in either direction, with few accurate elements. Exaggerated: a drop of blood sets off a frenzy, a shark roars. Understated or simply wrong: sharks shown as toothless or harmless by nature, able to live without eating animals, or "sharks don't get cancer".

      Why this level

      The animated film erroneously shows a great white shark (Lenny) that is perfectly able to survive without eating animals, instead being a kelp-eating vegetarian.

    • Motives & Risk

      Grossly distorted

      What this means for Motives & Risk

      Sharks' motives toward people are invented at the core: they hunt people out of human-like malice, revenge or a taste for humans (for example a shark that pursues one family to another ocean).

      Why this level

      The mafia gang of sharks terrorizes the reef out of malice, and Lenny is a heavily sanitized vegan shark friend. Two distortions in opposite directions are still two distortions.

    • Ecological Context

      Grossly distorted

      What this means for Ecological Context

      The picture of sharks in nature is false at its core: an impossible habitat or range shown as real (a prehistoric species alive in the deep sea), sharks as a plague the ocean would be better without, or people as their usual prey.

      Why this level

      Sharks operate a crime syndicate in a "reef" city and eat at restaurants.

    • Not applicableHuman Impact & Conservation

      Left out of the index

1 more expert rating counts toward the expert index but is not listed. Experts choose whether their ratings are listed with their name.

About this movie

The sea underworld is shaken up when the son of shark mob boss Don Lino (Robert De Niro) is found dead, and a young fish named Oscar (Will Smith) is found at the scene. Being a bottom feeder, Oscar takes advantage of the situation and makes himself look like he killed the finned mobster. Oscar soon comes to realize that his claim may have serious consequences.

Genres
Adventure, Comedy
Language
English
Director
Bibo Bergeron, Vicky Jenson, Rob Letterman
Starring
Will Smith, Robert De Niro, Renée Zellweger

IMDb page (opens in a new tab)

Data and poster from IMDb via OMDb (opens in a new tab)

Ratings from other sites

How critics and audiences on other sites rated this movie. These ratings have no influence on the Sharkuracy index.

IMDb
6.0 out of 10
Average of 211,362 IMDb users’ ratings
Rotten Tomatoes
35%
Critics’ reviews that are positive
Metacritic
48 out of 100
Weighted average of critics’ reviews

From IMDb, Rotten Tomatoes and Metacritic via OMDb (opens in a new tab), as of .